How to Make Salted Caramel Icecream!

by Big Guy Big Flavors

Salted caramel icecream is a favorite of mine. Subtly salty, subtly sweet, absoloutly divine! I snapped a few more steps than necessary, but it's really really simple to make.


  • 1 Cup Sugar
  • 4 Tablespoons Unsalted butter
  • 1 Teaspoon Coarse sea salt
  • 2 Cups Heavy cream
  • 1 Cup Whole milk
  • 6 Egg yolks
  • 1 Teaspoon Vanilla extract
  • To make the caramel ripples:
  • 1 Cup Sugar
  • 1 Pinch Coarse sea salt
  • 1 Tablespoon Unsalted butter
  • Instructions

    Step 1

    And of course, you will need an ice cream making machine, but worry not if you don't have one. There is an alternate method for making this recipe which doesn't require fancy machinery! :)

    Step 2

    Stir the sugar using a fork over medium heat.

    Step 3

    In the meantime, seperate the eggs and place the yolks in a medium bowl or jug. Discard the whites or save for another recipe.

    Step 4

    Once the sugar begins to brown and melt, set the fork away and start to swirl the pan to mix the sugar evenly but DO NOT stir!

    Step 5

    This is the exact color you want the caramel to be, a dark amber/ honey color! You may find that the sides of the pot might contain some grainy traces of sugar. That's fine, don't worry about it!

    Step 6

    Add the butter.

    Step 7

    Stir the butter using a wooden spoon or rubber scraper or spatula.

    Step 8

    Add the salt and stir.

    Step 9

    Add just 1 cup of the cream, reserve the other cup. It will begin to sizzle which is why it would be best to use a deep pot or pan to avoid flowing caramel. Continue stirring.

    Step 10

    Add the milk and keep stirring over low heat untill the mixture scalds and begins to steam.

    Step 11

    Whisk the egg yolks.

    Step 12

    Add half of your hot mixture into the egg yolks whilst continuosly whisking to prevent curdling the egg yolks. Although it doesn't show on the picture, I used a ladel to slowly pour the hot mixture.

    Step 13

    Add the mixture back to the pot whilst whisking continuosly.

    Step 14

    Keep stirring with a whisk or a wooden spoon/ rubber scraper or spatula over low-medium heat until the custard is thickened and creamy. It's done when it coats the back of a spoon.

    Step 15

    Remove frome heat and pour back into the bowl that we used earlier to whisk the eggs in. At that point, add the reserved cup of cream.

    Step 16

    Add the vanilla extract.

    Step 17

    Whisk untill thoroughly combined.

    Step 18

    Cover the surface of the custard with plastic wrap, NOT JUST THE RIM OF THE BOWL! We do this to prevent a skin-like crust from developing on top.

    Step 19

    Chill in an ice bath for an hour. An ice bath is to fill a large bowl third way with ice and 2 inches of water. Place the smaller bowl into the ice water. Make sure that you dont get water in the mix!

    Step 20

    The previous step is crucial to stop the cooking process or else the egg yolks will continue to cook. Skip this step & you will end up with a caramel flavoured, off putting curdled omelette! Not good!

    Step 21

    Once cooled down completely, remove from ice bath and whipe the bottom of the bowl with a towel or kitchen paper. And chill in the fridge overnight or 8 hours.

    Step 22

    Just before turning that custard into ice cream, make the caramel ribbon. Here's how to make that. ---->

    Step 23

    Just as we did at step 2, heat the sugar in a heavy based pan over low-medium heat. Stir with a fork to brown the caramel evenly. Stop stiring once the sugar begins to brown and start swirling the pan

    Step 24

    As the sugar is browning, line a heat-proof tray/ baking sheet with aluminum foil and add a teaspoon of veg shortening or vegetable oil or even softened butter.

    Step 25

    Use your hands to smear the shortening evenly on the sides and base of the tray. This is a crucial step to peel off the hardened caramel later.

    Step 26

    Look for an amber honey color

    Step 27

    Add the butter

    Step 28

    Stir and cook over low heat for a minute.

    Step 29

    Add the salt, stir and turn off the heat.

    Step 30

    Immediately pour into the lined tray/baking sheet and allow to cool completely. (pour the caramel very carefully to avoid a nasty burn)

    Step 31

    Once the custard is chilled, run it through a fine strainer to strain out any curdled lumps which will occur naturaly. I push it down the strainer using a ladel in circular motion.

    Step 32

    Once strained and smooth, pour into your ice cream maker.

    Step 33

    Let it churn in your ice cream maker according to the directions of the manufacturer's instructions. Don't have an ice cream maker? Follow the next step----->

    Step 34

    If you don't have an ice cream maker, here's what you could do: Put your custard in a deep plastic container. Allow to freeze for an hour. Pour custard into a blender or food processor. Blend. --->

    Step 35

    After blending, pour back into the plastic container and freeze. Repeat that process every 45 minutes for a total of 5 times. Obviously that method is time consuming but it gives a similar result.

    Step 36

    Once hardened, peel off the caramel slab out of the aluminum foil. It should peel off easily.

    Step 37

    Crack the caramel using a big knife. Cut or crack away into 1-2 inch bits and pieces, a few small shards are natural to happen.

    Step 38

    Pour your churned ice cream base into a plastic container.

    Step 39

    Add the crushed caramel and stir. How much you add is entirely up to you. Note that the caramel is hard now, but once it sits with the custard in the freezer, it will soften down real nice.

    Step 40

    Add a few more on top

    Step 41

    Pop a lid on the container, and you might as well just label it :)

    Step 42

    Freeze overnight. So close now!

    Step 43

    Scoop out, throw in a couple of chip ahoys to make ice cream sandwiches and go crazy!