How to Make Roly-Poly Santa Cookies

Been making these for years. Because they take more time, I make a small amount, but putting just one in the middle of a Christmas cookie platter makes a nice centerpiece.

7k Views 681 Likes
How to Make Roly-Poly Santa Cookies Recipe
13 Steps
Ingredients
Embed
1
Beat butter or margarine till softened. Add sugar and beat till fluffy. Beat in milk and vanilla. Add flour and beat till well mixed.

Beat butter or margarine till softened. Add sugar and beat till fluffy. Beat in milk and vanilla. Add flour and beat till well mixed.

2
Remove one cup of dough and color remaining dough red.

Remove one cup of dough and color remaining dough red.

Recommended For You
3
I use a pampered Chef Decorator for frosting, and the 2 tips shown. I store the mini chocolate chips in my freezer since recipe requires so few. They keep for 2-3 years.

I use a pampered Chef Decorator for frosting, and the 2 tips shown. I store the mini chocolate chips in my freezer since recipe requires so few. They keep for 2-3 years.

4
For each Santa: Using red, roll one 1" and five 1/2" balls. Using white, roll one 3/4" and four 1/4" balls.

For each Santa: Using red, roll one 1" and five 1/2" balls. Using white, roll one 3/4" and four 1/4" balls.

5
On in greased cookie sheet flatten 1" red to 1/2" for body. Attach 3/4" white ball for head: flatten to 1/2".

On in greased cookie sheet flatten 1" red to 1/2" for body. Attach 3/4" white ball for head: flatten to 1/2".

6
Form 1/2" balls for arms and legs and hat.

Form 1/2" balls for arms and legs and hat.

7
Attach white 1/4" balls to arms and legs and place chips in for eyes.  Note: 3 chips can be added as buttons down front of suit. Some years I do those... Some years I forget, like this year!

Attach white 1/4" balls to arms and legs and place chips in for eyes. Note: 3 chips can be added as buttons down front of suit. Some years I do those... Some years I forget, like this year!

8
Bake 325° for 12-15 minutes till edges are lightly browned. Cool 2 minutes on sheet.

Bake 325° for 12-15 minutes till edges are lightly browned. Cool 2 minutes on sheet.

9
Carefully remove to rack with thin spatula. Batch makes approx 12 cookies.

Carefully remove to rack with thin spatula. Batch makes approx 12 cookies.

10

SNOW FROSTING... Beat 1/2 C shortening & 1/2 tsp vanilla 30 sec. Gradually beat in 1-1/3 C powdered sugar. Add 1 T milk. Beat in 1 more C powdered sugar & 3-4 tsp milk to piping consistency.

11
Use plain tip to pipe hat, cuffs, down jacket  front & bottom. Use star tip to pipe beard and hat Pom Pom.

Use plain tip to pipe hat, cuffs, down jacket front & bottom. Use star tip to pipe beard and hat Pom Pom.

12
Very cute in the middle of your cookie platter.

Very cute in the middle of your cookie platter.

13
Tasty too!

Tasty too!

Ingredients

1 Cup Margarine or butter 
½ Cups Sugar 
1 Tablespoon Milk 
1 Teaspoon Vanilla 
Cups Flour 
Red food coloring 
MINI chocolate chips 
SNOW FROSTING 
½ Cups Shortening 
½ Teaspoons Vanilla 
1⅓ Cups Powdered sugar 
1 Tablespoon Milk 
1 Cup More of powdered sugar 
4 Teaspoons More of milk 
keyboard shortcuts:     previous step     next step
Comments
0 COMMENTS
View More Comments