How to Make Old Fashion Cream Pie

1.6k Views 227 Likes
How to Make Old Fashion Cream Pie Recipe
16 Steps
Ingredients
Embed
1
In a small cooker, blend well: I c sugar and 1/3 c flour

In a small cooker, blend well: I c sugar and 1/3 c flour

2
Add 1 cup heavy cream and 1 cup whole milk

Add 1 cup heavy cream and 1 cup whole milk

Recommended For You
3
Separate 3 eggs. Save those egg whites for the meringue! Add three egg YOLKS to the cream mixture

Separate 3 eggs. Save those egg whites for the meringue! Add three egg YOLKS to the cream mixture

4
Whisk well

Whisk well

5
Cook over medium heat. Stir well while it gets warm and stir especially after the cream starts to thicken. This will take about 7-10 minutes so be patient and keep stirring

Cook over medium heat. Stir well while it gets warm and stir especially after the cream starts to thicken. This will take about 7-10 minutes so be patient and keep stirring

6
While your cream pudding is cooking, brown your pie crust. I use the recipe from my guides: Derby Pie.

While your cream pudding is cooking, brown your pie crust. I use the recipe from my guides: Derby Pie.

7
Here is what the pudding looks like once it's thickened.

Here is what the pudding looks like once it's thickened.

8
Once it's removed from heat and thick, add 2 Tb butter and a tsp pure vanilla.

Once it's removed from heat and thick, add 2 Tb butter and a tsp pure vanilla.

9
Pour the pudding into pie shells. I made both kinds, vanilla and chocolate. If you want chocolate you add your semi sweet chips to the cream mixture as it warms and thickens.

Pour the pudding into pie shells. I made both kinds, vanilla and chocolate. If you want chocolate you add your semi sweet chips to the cream mixture as it warms and thickens.

10
Meringue: over a double boiler, take the 3 egg whites and 3/4 c sugar. Let that warm for 10 minutes. Then pour into mixer and beat w a pinch of cream of tarter. Whip until it holds stiff peaks

Meringue: over a double boiler, take the 3 egg whites and 3/4 c sugar. Let that warm for 10 minutes. Then pour into mixer and beat w a pinch of cream of tarter. Whip until it holds stiff peaks

11
Big dollops of the meringue on top of pie

Big dollops of the meringue on top of pie

12
With a small spoon, Push meringue from the middle of pie to very edge of pie dish

With a small spoon, Push meringue from the middle of pie to very edge of pie dish

13
It's important to cover meringue to edges well, otherwise when you brown off meringue it will shrink back away from pie

It's important to cover meringue to edges well, otherwise when you brown off meringue it will shrink back away from pie

14
So get it to the very edge of pie dish

So get it to the very edge of pie dish

15
Bake at 375 for about 5-7 minutes. Keep checking it as it browns

Bake at 375 for about 5-7 minutes. Keep checking it as it browns

16
Let cool (or not :) and enjoy!

Let cool (or not :) and enjoy!

Ingredients

1 Cup Sugar 
Cups Flour 
1 Cup Heavy cream 
1 Cup Whole milk 
3 Egg YOLKS 
1 Teaspoon Vanilla extract 
2 Tablespoons Butter 
keyboard shortcuts:     previous step     next step
Comments
0 COMMENTS
View More Comments