How to Make BETTER Peanut Brittle Than Money Can Buy!

For 40 years Peanut Brittle lovers tell me this is the best they've ever eaten. It's from my Betty Crocker Cookbook, but over 4 decades I've perfected it & have tips to share.

7.4k Views 652 Likes 3 Comments
How to Make BETTER Peanut Brittle Than Money Can Buy! Recipe
35 Steps
Ingredients
Embed
1

MUST HAVE!... Heavy 6 quart Dutch Oven pot. Mine is an old 1970's Club Aluminum. It's perfect! You need a heavy THICK pot so it won't scorch. (They can be found at thrift stores & garage sales.)

2
TIP: Simple to measure out 3 Tbsp's by reading wrapper. Just cut off section.

TIP: Simple to measure out 3 Tbsp's by reading wrapper. Just cut off section.

Recommended For You
3
TIP:  I set butter on top of peanuts as they're both poured into hot mixture at once when you need to move quickly.

TIP: I set butter on top of peanuts as they're both poured into hot mixture at once when you need to move quickly.

4

Gather supplies. Heat oven to 270°. Measure and mix 1-1/2 Cups sugar & 1 cup each light corn syrup and water into your pot. Attach candy thermometer to edge.

5
You also need short tiny spatula & small plastic bowl so vanilla, soda & water is ready to add quickly.

You also need short tiny spatula & small plastic bowl so vanilla, soda & water is ready to add quickly.

6
Using paper towel, grease 2 cookie sheets with butter. I use non-stick pans.

Using paper towel, grease 2 cookie sheets with butter. I use non-stick pans.

7
It's important to generously grease entire surface.

It's important to generously grease entire surface.

8
Place cookie sheets into warm oven. The key to being able to spread peanut brittle is having the cookie sheets WARM.

Place cookie sheets into warm oven. The key to being able to spread peanut brittle is having the cookie sheets WARM.

9
Measure vanilla, soda & water into small container. TIP: Use tiny spatula and have it mixed and ready. It WILL separate so at the last minute you'll have to mix again & pour in QUCKLY!

Measure vanilla, soda & water into small container. TIP: Use tiny spatula and have it mixed and ready. It WILL separate so at the last minute you'll have to mix again & pour in QUCKLY!

10
You'll have to re-mix again at the last seconds.

You'll have to re-mix again at the last seconds.

11
I fill to 1 cup line with HOT water, them pour corn syrup on top to 2-cup line. TIP: hot water just makes it easier to pour both out into dutch oven.

I fill to 1 cup line with HOT water, them pour corn syrup on top to 2-cup line. TIP: hot water just makes it easier to pour both out into dutch oven.

12
Mix sugar, 1 cup water and 1 cup corn syrup into Dutch oven pot.

Mix sugar, 1 cup water and 1 cup corn syrup into Dutch oven pot.

13
Stir to mix with wooden spoon.

Stir to mix with wooden spoon.

14
MUST HAVE... Oven mitts. (I know of someone who needed 3 surgeries due to peanut brittle burns.) Be very careful!

MUST HAVE... Oven mitts. (I know of someone who needed 3 surgeries due to peanut brittle burns.) Be very careful!

15
I set burner to high and watch closely.

I set burner to high and watch closely.

16
Early on it boils vigorously but only needs occasional stirring.

Early on it boils vigorously but only needs occasional stirring.

17
As it approaches 240°, you'll need to stir more.

As it approaches 240°, you'll need to stir more.

18
First step is to get it to 240°. TIP: You need to scoop mixture up onto thermometer to get accurate reading.

First step is to get it to 240°. TIP: You need to scoop mixture up onto thermometer to get accurate reading.

19
Approaching 240° it. Gets thicker and turns more of a yellow color. Be ready to pour in peanuts and butter as soon as it reaches 240°!

Approaching 240° it. Gets thicker and turns more of a yellow color. Be ready to pour in peanuts and butter as soon as it reaches 240°!

20
Now you will stir vigorously to 300° and move cookie sheets from oven to counter. I often get my husband's help with this if he's around & to stir in the soda,water, vanilla mixture. Otherwise I do it

Now you will stir vigorously to 300° and move cookie sheets from oven to counter. I often get my husband's help with this if he's around & to stir in the soda,water, vanilla mixture. Otherwise I do it

21
I hold the thermometer and edge of pan together. The oven mitts are critical.

I hold the thermometer and edge of pan together. The oven mitts are critical.

22
You MUST keep the mixture moving to avoid scorching. You WILL feel it in your wrist.

You MUST keep the mixture moving to avoid scorching. You WILL feel it in your wrist.

23

TIP: peanut brittle MUST REACH 300° ! This is what makes it a hard crack.

24
Once it reaches 300° remove from heat IMMEDIATELY pour in soda, water, vanilla mixture in. My husband filmed the stirring for this guide and he poured in the vanilla mixture.

Once it reaches 300° remove from heat IMMEDIATELY pour in soda, water, vanilla mixture in. My husband filmed the stirring for this guide and he poured in the vanilla mixture.

25
It will sizzle & steam when the soda, water, vanilla hits it. You must stir it in QUICKLY. It will brown up the peanut brittle and smell delicious at this point.

It will sizzle & steam when the soda, water, vanilla hits it. You must stir it in QUICKLY. It will brown up the peanut brittle and smell delicious at this point.

26
Pour onto WARM, buttered cookie sheets and quickly spread.

Pour onto WARM, buttered cookie sheets and quickly spread.

27
First I spread with wooden spoon and then switch to my Pampered Chef silicone spatula because it doesn't stick and won't melt from the HOT mixture.

First I spread with wooden spoon and then switch to my Pampered Chef silicone spatula because it doesn't stick and won't melt from the HOT mixture.

28
This spatula works great!

This spatula works great!

29
Since sheets are warm, you have a couple minutes to spread evenly.

Since sheets are warm, you have a couple minutes to spread evenly.

30

Let cool on sheets on wire rack.

31
Once cooled, it should lift right off cookie sheets.

Once cooled, it should lift right off cookie sheets.

32
Because it was cooked to 300°, it will be nice and brittle!

Because it was cooked to 300°, it will be nice and brittle!

33
I give Peanut Brittle as gifts at Christmas. It stores well in covered container at room temperature away from high humidity.

I give Peanut Brittle as gifts at Christmas. It stores well in covered container at room temperature away from high humidity.

34
If you're a Peanut Brittle fan, I guarantee you will love this! I didn't really eat it much for almost 40 years. For me it was fun to make it for others.

If you're a Peanut Brittle fan, I guarantee you will love this! I didn't really eat it much for almost 40 years. For me it was fun to make it for others.

35

I dedicate this to my Dad who loves Peanut Brittle. Because of him I first learned to make it & for 40 years, was his birthday, Fathers Day & Christmas gift. He suffers dementia now at 84. Love ya Dad

Ingredients

1 Pounds Dry roasted peanuts 
3 Tablespoons Butter 
Cups Sugar 
1 Cup Light corn syrup 
1 Cup Water 
Teaspoons Baking soda 
1 Teaspoon Vanilla 
1 Teaspoon Water 
keyboard shortcuts:     previous step     next step
Comments
3 COMMENTS
View More Comments