How to Bake a Fabulous Crumb Cake

I apologize if this is crack to you. It is to me.

9.1k Views 1386 Likes 4 Comments
How to Bake a Fabulous Crumb Cake Recipe
27 Steps
Ingredients
Embed
1
This used to be called New York Crumb Cake but they lost the title when they started chasing the calories and salt out of all 5 boroughs. You can't even get it there .

This used to be called New York Crumb Cake but they lost the title when they started chasing the calories and salt out of all 5 boroughs. You can't even get it there .

2
Here are the ingredients for the crumbs. Put it all in a bowl. If you'd like to skip the mess of measuring cups , it's 2 1/2 oz each  of the sugars and 8 oz flour.

Here are the ingredients for the crumbs. Put it all in a bowl. If you'd like to skip the mess of measuring cups , it's 2 1/2 oz each of the sugars and 8 oz flour.

Recommended For You
3
This is how you measure with cups.

This is how you measure with cups.

4
Now you have to get that flour back in the box, which, as you know, has a plastic bag with a too small hole cut in it. You'll probably throw it away.

Now you have to get that flour back in the box, which, as you know, has a plastic bag with a too small hole cut in it. You'll probably throw it away.

5
So, try this. You'll never go back.

So, try this. You'll never go back.

6
If you don't have some of this, go over to Penzey's and stick your nose in their jars.  They have different kinds of cinnamon . Who knew?

If you don't have some of this, go over to Penzey's and stick your nose in their jars. They have different kinds of cinnamon . Who knew?

7
Melt the butter.

Melt the butter.

8
Spray an 8x8 square pan with Pam for Baking and line it with parchment comme ca. Later, you will be able to lift the cake out of the pan w/out losing a crumb. You'll see.

Spray an 8x8 square pan with Pam for Baking and line it with parchment comme ca. Later, you will be able to lift the cake out of the pan w/out losing a crumb. You'll see.

9
Stir the dry ingredients.

Stir the dry ingredients.

10
Pour in the butter.

Pour in the butter.

11
Stir until it looks like this. It doesn't take long and don't break up the big ones. We want those.

Stir until it looks like this. It doesn't take long and don't break up the big ones. We want those.

12
You don't have to buy this excellent vanilla by the quart. But you have to buy it.

You don't have to buy this excellent vanilla by the quart. But you have to buy it.

13
Put all the dry ingredients in the bowl of your mixer. That's 6oz flour, 3 1/4 oz sugar for you weighing types. Blend it briefly then add the butter

Put all the dry ingredients in the bowl of your mixer. That's 6oz flour, 3 1/4 oz sugar for you weighing types. Blend it briefly then add the butter

14
Mix until the butter looks like little pebbles. Then add the wet ingredients , shown here. Save the extra egg white- we might make meringues.

Mix until the butter looks like little pebbles. Then add the wet ingredients , shown here. Save the extra egg white- we might make meringues.

15
Get all the stuff mixed then scrape the bowl. Turn mixer to medium and mix one minute. No, seriously , set the timer.

Get all the stuff mixed then scrape the bowl. Turn mixer to medium and mix one minute. No, seriously , set the timer.

16
Because after one minute, the batter will be fluffy and gorgeous. See?

Because after one minute, the batter will be fluffy and gorgeous. See?

17
Put it in the pan. It's petty thick so get out your trusty off-set spatula and start spreading.

Put it in the pan. It's petty thick so get out your trusty off-set spatula and start spreading.

18
I love that little tool.

I love that little tool.

19
It will look like this. Now, the good part.

It will look like this. Now, the good part.

20
The crumbs! The ne plus ultra of all toppings. The topping to which all other nuts and icings aspire. The reason you bought an elliptical.  And the reason you need an elliptical.

The crumbs! The ne plus ultra of all toppings. The topping to which all other nuts and icings aspire. The reason you bought an elliptical. And the reason you need an elliptical.

21
Start by putting crumbs on the edges and work into the middle. We want big crumbs, which if you followed directions, will be plentiful

Start by putting crumbs on the edges and work into the middle. We want big crumbs, which if you followed directions, will be plentiful

22
One of the beauties of this cake- the crumbs stay where you put them. No moving from the edges to the middle which causes some of your relatives to eat the middle first. The filet, so to speak .

One of the beauties of this cake- the crumbs stay where you put them. No moving from the edges to the middle which causes some of your relatives to eat the middle first. The filet, so to speak .

23
There will be smaller crumbs at the bottom of the bowl. Squish them into big crumbs and cover that thing.

There will be smaller crumbs at the bottom of the bowl. Squish them into big crumbs and cover that thing.

24
Ooh la la. Ready to go in the oven at 325. Bake for 30 minutes then test with a toothpick. Should come out clean.

Ooh la la. Ready to go in the oven at 325. Bake for 30 minutes then test with a toothpick. Should come out clean.

25
See? All the crumbs are right where you left them. Let it cool until you can touch the pan. Then lift it out, using those nifty parchment handles I showed you.

See? All the crumbs are right where you left them. Let it cool until you can touch the pan. Then lift it out, using those nifty parchment handles I showed you.

26
You should buy a pretty, square plate, just for this. We both know you're going to make this a lot.  You can dust with a bit of powdered sugar. Or not.

You should buy a pretty, square plate, just for this. We both know you're going to make this a lot. You can dust with a bit of powdered sugar. Or not.

27
Wall to wall crumbs. No filet. Enjoy. Then, back on the elliptical.

Wall to wall crumbs. No filet. Enjoy. Then, back on the elliptical.

Ingredients

Crumbs  
Cups Brown sugar 
Cups Sugar 
4 Ounces Unsalted butter 
¾ Teaspoons Cinnamon 
Cups Cake flour 
1 Pinch Salt 
Cake 
Cups Cake flour 
½ Cups Sugar 
¼ Teaspoons Baking soda 
¼ Teaspoons Salt 
4 Ounces Unsalted butter 
½ Teaspoons Vanilla 
1 Jumbo egg 
1 Jumbo egg yolk 
2 Teaspoons Buttermilk 
keyboard shortcuts:     previous step     next step
Comments
4 COMMENTS
View More Comments