How to Make Pumpkin Pie Cake😋

Start the Guide
Make Pumpkin Pie Cake😋

How to Make Pumpkin Pie Cake😋

It's not pie...It's not cake..It's Pie Cake!

1.5k Views
Step 1 of 56
Start with 1 box Cake Mix. I used Carrot. But can also use Yellow, Spice, or any flavor you like with Pumpkin.

Start with 1 box Cake Mix. I used Carrot. But can also use Yellow, Spice, or any flavor you like with Pumpkin.

Step 2 of 56
Set aside 1 cup of Cake Mix for topping.

Set aside 1 cup of Cake Mix for topping.

Step 3 of 56
Pour rest of Cake Mix in mixing bowl.

Pour rest of Cake Mix in mixing bowl.

Step 4 of 56
Take out 1 stick of Butter.

Take out 1 stick of Butter.

Step 5 of 56
Dice up.

Dice up.

Step 6 of 56
Add to Cake Mix.

Add to Cake Mix.

Step 7 of 56
Get one egg. 🐓

Get one egg. 🐓

Step 8 of 56
Poke hole in yolk in separate cup.

Poke hole in yolk in separate cup.

Step 9 of 56
Beat well.

Beat well.

Step 10 of 56
Add to Cake Mixture.

Add to Cake Mixture.

Step 11 of 56
Mix well.

Mix well.

Step 12 of 56
Will look like this.

Will look like this.

Step 13 of 56
Prepare 9x13 cake pan with Spray oil.

Prepare 9x13 cake pan with Spray oil.

Step 14 of 56
Dump in Cake Mixture.

Dump in Cake Mixture.

Step 15 of 56
With oiled hands, press mix all around pan.

With oiled hands, press mix all around pan.

Step 16 of 56
Like this.

Like this.

Step 17 of 56

Set this aside. This is "Cake" part. And now for the "Pie" part.

Step 18 of 56
Start with large pan on stove. Don't turn on heat yet.

Start with large pan on stove. Don't turn on heat yet.

Step 19 of 56
Measure out about 28 ounces of Pumpkin Puree. Check out my guide on how to make your own at home.

Measure out about 28 ounces of Pumpkin Puree. Check out my guide on how to make your own at home.

Step 20 of 56
Dump into pan.

Dump into pan.

Step 21 of 56
Measure out 2 cups sugar.

Measure out 2 cups sugar.

Step 22 of 56
Add to Pumpkin.

Add to Pumpkin.

Step 23 of 56
Measure and add 2 teaspoons of cinnamon.

Measure and add 2 teaspoons of cinnamon.

Step 24 of 56
Add pinch of salt.

Add pinch of salt.

Step 25 of 56
Add 4 eggs, beaten well.

Add 4 eggs, beaten well.

Step 26 of 56
Eggs in!

Eggs in!

Step 27 of 56
Measure out 1 cup milk.

Measure out 1 cup milk.

Step 28 of 56
Add in.

Add in.

Step 29 of 56
And 1 Tablespoon of Butter.

And 1 Tablespoon of Butter.

Step 30 of 56
All in!

All in!

Step 31 of 56
Turn heat on low.

Turn heat on low.

Step 32 of 56
Start stirring.

Start stirring.

Step 33 of 56
Preheat oven to 350 degrees and preset timer for 1 hour.

Preheat oven to 350 degrees and preset timer for 1 hour.

Step 34 of 56
When biggest part is mixed well, switch to whisk to incorporate the cinnamon.

When biggest part is mixed well, switch to whisk to incorporate the cinnamon.

Step 35 of 56
Stir, cover and heat, wait 5 min. Stir, cover and heat. Repeat till well mixed, starts to boil and thickens.

Stir, cover and heat, wait 5 min. Stir, cover and heat. Repeat till well mixed, starts to boil and thickens.

Step 36 of 56

While waiting in between stirs. Start on topping.

Step 37 of 56
For topping, start with 3 Tablespoons butter.

For topping, start with 3 Tablespoons butter.

Step 38 of 56
Dice up.

Dice up.

Step 39 of 56
Add that 1 cup of reserved Cake Mix.

Add that 1 cup of reserved Cake Mix.

Step 40 of 56
With fork or pastry cutter, mash butter into cake mix till looks crumbly.

With fork or pastry cutter, mash butter into cake mix till looks crumbly.

Step 41 of 56
Like this.

Like this.

Step 42 of 56
Now back to pie part. All mixed well.

Now back to pie part. All mixed well.

Step 43 of 56
Starting to boil. Still only on low heat. Time to check for thickness.

Starting to boil. Still only on low heat. Time to check for thickness.

Step 44 of 56
See how it just hangs to the spoon. Yep, it's thick enough. Now blow it, and taste it.

See how it just hangs to the spoon. Yep, it's thick enough. Now blow it, and taste it.

Step 45 of 56
Blow..blow!

Blow..blow!

Step 46 of 56
Taste it. Do you like the taste?  Does it need more sugar? More cinnamon?  Now's the time to add. If not, ready to pour over that set aside cake part.

Taste it. Do you like the taste? Does it need more sugar? More cinnamon? Now's the time to add. If not, ready to pour over that set aside cake part.

Step 47 of 56
Pour all in.

Pour all in.

Step 48 of 56
Now, get that crumb topping and add to top.

Now, get that crumb topping and add to top.

Step 49 of 56
Like so.

Like so.

Step 50 of 56
Place in preheated oven.

Place in preheated oven.

Step 51 of 56
About 30 min later.

About 30 min later.

Step 52 of 56
Looks like this. Starting to smell good in here!

Looks like this. Starting to smell good in here!

Step 53 of 56
Start checking after 45 min. Shake the pan to see if middle moves. When no longer jiggles, check it.

Start checking after 45 min. Shake the pan to see if middle moves. When no longer jiggles, check it.

Step 54 of 56
With toothpick, insert in middle, should come out fairly clean. Not like a cake. But more like brownies. Pie part will be very soft, but firm.

With toothpick, insert in middle, should come out fairly clean. Not like a cake. But more like brownies. Pie part will be very soft, but firm.

Step 55 of 56
Check out the side looks like a very moist cake.

Check out the side looks like a very moist cake.

Step 56 of 56
The topping is crunchy..the pie part is super moist, the cake part is like a brownie. Topped with whipped topping..Mmm..Mmm. 😋Enjoy!

The topping is crunchy..the pie part is super moist, the cake part is like a brownie. Topped with whipped topping..Mmm..Mmm. 😋Enjoy!

You're Done

Check out other guides by this author!

Commonwealth of Kentucky
Married to my Best Friend, Mother of Three Wonderful Children, Nurse at a Children's Hospital and Love..Love Getting a Bargain!

Keep Exploring

Start Over

7 Comments
Supplies

1 Box of Cake Mix

1 Stick of Butter

1 Egg

28 Ounces Pumpkin Puree

2 Cups Sugar

2 Teaspoons Cinnamon

Pinch of Salt

4 Eggs

1 Cup Milk

1 Tablespoon Butter

3 Tablespoons Butter

Whipped Topping

Miss Apple

You're welcome. :)

Miss Apple 7 months ago

Lucy Hudnall

I so hear you, same here. And thank you. :)

(author) 7 months ago

Miss Apple

I really shouldn't look at food guides when I'm hungry...that looks awesome.

Miss Apple 7 months ago

Lucy Hudnall

Wonderful Erin!

(author) 7 months ago

💋Karatecutie 💋

Looks great!!! I'm gonna make tomorow!

💋Karatecutie 💋 7 months ago

Lucy Hudnall

Thank you Rane!

(author) 7 months ago

Rane Body Decor

This is brilliant.....

Rane Body Decor 7 months ago

Be first to comment on Step 1.

Be first to comment on Step 2.

Be first to comment on Step 3.

Be first to comment on Step 4.

Be first to comment on Step 5.

Be first to comment on Step 6.

Be first to comment on Step 7.

Be first to comment on Step 8.

Be first to comment on Step 9.

Be first to comment on Step 10.

Be first to comment on Step 11.

Be first to comment on Step 12.

Be first to comment on Step 13.

Be first to comment on Step 14.

Be first to comment on Step 15.

Be first to comment on Step 16.

Be first to comment on Step 17.

Be first to comment on Step 18.

Be first to comment on Step 19.

Be first to comment on Step 20.

Be first to comment on Step 21.

Be first to comment on Step 22.

Be first to comment on Step 23.

Be first to comment on Step 24.

Be first to comment on Step 25.

Be first to comment on Step 26.

Be first to comment on Step 27.

Be first to comment on Step 28.

Be first to comment on Step 29.

Be first to comment on Step 30.

Be first to comment on Step 31.

Be first to comment on Step 32.

Be first to comment on Step 33.

Be first to comment on Step 34.

Be first to comment on Step 35.

Be first to comment on Step 36.

Be first to comment on Step 37.

Be first to comment on Step 38.

Be first to comment on Step 39.

Be first to comment on Step 40.

Be first to comment on Step 41.

Be first to comment on Step 42.

Be first to comment on Step 43.

Be first to comment on Step 44.

Be first to comment on Step 45.

Be first to comment on Step 46.

Be first to comment on Step 47.

Be first to comment on Step 48.

Be first to comment on Step 49.

Be first to comment on Step 50.

Be first to comment on Step 51.

Be first to comment on Step 52.

Be first to comment on Step 53.

Be first to comment on Step 54.

Be first to comment on Step 55.

Be first to comment on Step 56.