How to Make Old-Fashioned Hand Churned Butter

The old fashioned method of hand churning butter is something that should be tried at least once during a lifetime.

5.9k Views 151 Likes 10 Comments
Image for Step 1

Gather ingredients and tools. I used a butter churn from Lehman's but you can also use a mason jar with a top. If you want a quicker version, you can use a food processor.

Image for Step 2

Let the cream sit out at room temperature to ripen for 2-3 hours. Pour the cream into the butter churn.

Recommended For You
Image for Step 3

After letting the cream sit at room temperature for 2 1/2 hours to ripen, you can see the thickness of the cream form at the top of the jar.

Video Placeholder Image for Step 4

Start to hand crank the churner. If using a mason jar, start to shake the jar vigorously. The cream will go through several stages before the butter separates. It took me about 35-40 minutes.

Image for Step 5

After 35 minutes, you can see the cream "seized" and turned to butter. The liquid in the middle is buttermilk.

Image for Step 6

Strain the butter and buttermilk over a bowl. Don't discard the buttermilk. Save it for Sunday pancakes. :) My butter yielded one cup of buttermilk .

Image for Step 7

Here is a close up of the butter on top and the buttermilk straining on the bottom.

Video Placeholder Image for Step 8

Use a wooden spoon and press down on the butter to remove the buttermilk.

Video Placeholder Image for Step 9

You must remove all remaining buttermilk from the butter or it will turn sour and be inedible. Rinse under cold water until the water runs clear. I rinsed mine about 12 times.

Image for Step 10

Once the water runs clear, your butter is ready! Add a couple pinches of high quality flake salt. Refrigerate the butter an airtight container or roll it in wax paper. Get ready for a treat!

keyboard shortcuts:     previous step     next step
View More Comments