How to Make Derby Pie

Start the Guide
make Derby Pie

How to Make Derby Pie

3.3k Views
Step 1 of 17
Start the pie filling: 1 c sugar, 1 cup light corn syrup

Start the pie filling: 1 c sugar, 1 cup light corn syrup

Step 2 of 17
Add 5TB butter and bring to a gentle boil medium low heat. Allow to boil about 4-5 minutes

Add 5TB butter and bring to a gentle boil medium low heat. Allow to boil about 4-5 minutes

Step 3 of 17
Once finished, sit aside and let cool for 20 minutes.  Allow three eggs to come to room temp and start the pie crust

Once finished, sit aside and let cool for 20 minutes. Allow three eggs to come to room temp and start the pie crust

Step 4 of 17
In a food processor, or use a pastry cutter..pulse together: 2 1/2 c flour, 2TB sugar, 1tsp salt, 1/2 cold butter and 1/2 cup vegetable shortening

In a food processor, or use a pastry cutter..pulse together: 2 1/2 c flour, 2TB sugar, 1tsp salt, 1/2 cold butter and 1/2 cup vegetable shortening

Step 5 of 17
Pulse until it resemble large crumble

Pulse until it resemble large crumble

Step 6 of 17
Add enough COLD water until it starts to form  a ball. Start with 1/4 cup and keep adding as needed. This makes a double pie crust

Add enough COLD water until it starts to form a ball. Start with 1/4 cup and keep adding as needed. This makes a double pie crust

Step 7 of 17
To roll out dough, I lay down two pieces of plastic wrap

To roll out dough, I lay down two pieces of plastic wrap

Step 8 of 17
Form a disc, and flour the surface

Form a disc, and flour the surface

Step 9 of 17
Lay another layer of plastic wrap over the dough and roll out to about 1/2 inch thickness

Lay another layer of plastic wrap over the dough and roll out to about 1/2 inch thickness

Step 10 of 17
Remove the top layer of wrap, and pick the bottom up so that you can flip over your hand to move to pie dish

Remove the top layer of wrap, and pick the bottom up so that you can flip over your hand to move to pie dish

Step 11 of 17
Place over hand..

Place over hand..

Step 12 of 17
And form to your design  I like a more rustic looking pie shell. I don't pinch or fork the edges

And form to your design I like a more rustic looking pie shell. I don't pinch or fork the edges

Step 13 of 17
Remaining dough; shape a disc and wrap in plastic. Then freezer bag. Into the freezer

Remaining dough; shape a disc and wrap in plastic. Then freezer bag. Into the freezer

Step 14 of 17
Cover the bottom of pie shell with 1/2 cup pecans and as many choc chips as you want.  I use semi sweet

Cover the bottom of pie shell with 1/2 cup pecans and as many choc chips as you want. I use semi sweet

Step 15 of 17
Then add one egg at a time into your filling. Stir quickly bc the filling is hot. Once done, Pour into pie shell, over the nuts and chocolate

Then add one egg at a time into your filling. Stir quickly bc the filling is hot. Once done, Pour into pie shell, over the nuts and chocolate

Step 16 of 17
Bake 325 for about 55-60 minutes. The filling will be a little jiggly when you remove. That's ok, it will sit up as it cools

Bake 325 for about 55-60 minutes. The filling will be a little jiggly when you remove. That's ok, it will sit up as it cools

Step 17 of 17
Crunchy top, rich crust and caramel-y center! Enjoy

Crunchy top, rich crust and caramel-y center! Enjoy

You're Done

Check out other guides by this author!

Below the Mason Dixon line
sugarplumsdance.wordpress.com
I heart food y'all

Keep Exploring

Start Over

9 Comments
0 Supplies
Nikki Lyon

Snowrose, my mom makes it the traditional way, w about a TB of bourbon and she adds it w the vanilla and eggs. Which would be at the end of cooking and cooling the filling. It is a pretty strong taste and is why I omit it. I hate to say I'm a ky gal and don't care for bourbon (unless it's a drink;) but I just don't like it in desserts

(author) 9 months ago

Heidi Feldman

If bourbon (Kentucky! where else for a 'Derby Pie'?!!!) smile... But if bourbon is used, what's the taste like? Strong, overly empowering? Or what please? How much bourbon is used?

Heidi Feldman 9 months ago

Nikki Lyon

I will Daniel. I typically don't put up supplies bc I add amounts as the pages are up but I'll go back and add :) enjoy

(author) 9 months ago

Mary Breinholt

My sister lived in Kentucky for awhile and one year she sent me a new pie plate the recipe and the ingredients. It was so yummy!! I had forgotten about it thanks I must bring out the recipe again!!!!

Mary Breinholt 9 months ago

Daniel Raffel

Great guide, Nikki - looks delicious! Any chance you could add all the necessary supplies? I wanna make it!

Daniel Raffel 9 months ago

Nikki Lyon

Priscilla, I'm originally from KY, where the derby is held. Typically the pie has bourbon in it but I don't prefer it that way :) enjoy! I make it almost every week!

(author) 9 months ago

Priscilla Rivera

Never heard of this type of pie before. Looks yummy though, can't wait to try it. :)

Priscilla Rivera 9 months ago

Nikki Lyon

Thank you Georgia !! :)

(author) 9 months ago

Georgia Phillips

I love your recipes!

Georgia Phillips 9 months ago

Be first to comment on Step 1.

Be first to comment on Step 2.

Be first to comment on Step 3.

Be first to comment on Step 4.

Be first to comment on Step 5.

Be first to comment on Step 6.

Be first to comment on Step 7.

Be first to comment on Step 8.

Be first to comment on Step 9.

Be first to comment on Step 10.

Be first to comment on Step 11.

Be first to comment on Step 12.

Be first to comment on Step 13.

Be first to comment on Step 14.

Be first to comment on Step 15.

Be first to comment on Step 16.

Be first to comment on Step 17.